Indo-Nepal relationship in need of an overhaul

                 

Nepal and India shares a special relationship since time immemorial. The dynamics of Indo-Nepal relationship cannot be ascertained without comprehending multi factors upon which the relationship of both the countries is based on. As neighbors, Nepal and India are not only linked by land mass but also have many common grounds of mutual cooperation and understandings. Two countries are linked culturally, religiously, economically, and also politically.  In spite of this special bonding between the two countries, many a times bilateral disputes arise which have strained the climate of trust and boding. Such conditions have been prevalent now in Nepal after the promulgation of constitution, in which some of the suggestions of the Indian establishment were ignored by the Nepalese political parties. These difficult conditions are not new, but result of Indian interfering behavior of India, based on the faulty treaties between Nepal and India, which needs a timely review and renewal to strengthen the relationship between the two countries.

Nepal foreign policy is largely based on two doctrine of foreign policy of its founder King Prithvi Narayan Shan which states: “Nepal is a sandwich between India and China”, and “Do not involve in offense, but any warfare should be based on defensive basis only.” Thus these two principles can be taken as the pillars of foreign policy of Nepal.

Though formal diplomatic relationship was established only on 13^th June, 1947, Indo-Nepal relationship has been marked by extensive cooperation and mutual understanding, crossing the limits of formality. The relationship between the two countries is one of its kind and very much inter-related and inter-dependent. Many a times, foreign affairs experts opine that the policy of Nepal with India is in fact the foreign policy of Nepal.

One of an important dynamics of Indo-Nepal relations is the latter’s economic dependence on India. Nepal gets 2/3 of its exports from Indian, including necessities like petroleum products for which it totally depends on India. Its current trade deficit with India has crossed USD 3.80 billion, and is ever increasing. India also has been contributing on the political developments in Nepal, which most of the time has been debatable, leading backlash in both the countries. Pioneer leaders of Nepalese political parties were involved in the Indian Independence movement and had a good relationship with the leaders like MK Gandhi, Nehru, Lohia, etc. After the Indian independence, it assisted the political transition in Nepal with the advent of constitutional monarchy and multiparty democracy by ousting the 104 years Rana oligarchy. Since then India has been having a say in political developments in Nepal and has been using it as a mechanism to maintain its big brotherhood attitude in Nepal.

While, as a buffer state between India and China, Nepal has been successful to maintain an arm’s length distance between its immediate neighbors. Nepal is committed to avoid the use of its land against security concerns of India (terrorism, money laundering etc.) and as also vividly supports one-China policy.  Nepalese delegates keep on reiterating these policies whenever they are engaged in mutual discourse with the delegation from its immediate neighbors. As such it can be said that Nepal has been able to address the security concern of its neighboring countries.

Among the earliest treaty between India and Nepal is Peace and Friendship treaty-1950 which envisions a common custom regime, free employment, and free movement across border, etc. While the basic structure of governance in India remains the same, it has undergone massive change in Nepal since the Peace and Friendship treaty of 1950 was signed. Thus time and again the need to amend 65 years old treaty is felt.

Over the years there have been quite a few instances of ups and downs in the Indo-Nepal relationship. 1990 blockade, Mahakhali treaty, Pancheswar Treaty, Bhutanese refugee issue, border disputes in Susta and Lipulek , and recent unofficial blockade of India after the promulgation of the constitution in Nepal, etc are few to name. These issues led to a massive outpour of anti-Indian sentiments in Nepal, which had led the relationship between the countries to a record low

The sooner the better, leaders from both the countries should realize that foreign relation based on the principle of Panchasheel, UN charter, international norms of Peace and welfare etc.  can help. As per the need of the time, India and Nepal should overhaul the diplomatic relationship and also the relevant treaties which lay foundation to such relationship. This can lead towards foundation of trust in upcoming diplomatic courses between the countries. Similarly India should stop meddling into political happenings in Nepal which while focusing on the miniature affairs, may end up jeopardizing its strategic concerns in Nepal. In the same way, Nepalese political leaders should display maturity in dealing with its giant neighbor. Nepalese government should consolidate the foreign policy of the country and empower foreign ministry to execute its diplomatic affairs.

In the recent context India should have been gracious in welcoming Nepal’s new constitution while registering its reservations/suggestions. Thus, India need to immediately correct the course and remove the blockade in Nepal and create a congenial environment for overhauling the overall diplomatic relations between the two countries.